2.1 Independent vs. Agency-Assisted Surrogacy: Which is Right for You?

If you’re thinking about becoming a surrogate, one of the biggest decisions you'll face is whether to go through an agency or do it on your own. Independent surrogacy—where you manage the entire process without an agency—might sound appealing at first. Some women are drawn to the idea of having more control or helping intended parents save money on agency fees.

But before you take that path, it’s important to understand what it really involves. While it can work in some situations, independent surrogacy often comes with more risk, more responsibility, and more stress than people realize.

For both first-time and experienced surrogates, working with a professional agency like GSHC Surrogacy & Egg Donation usually means more protection, more peace of mind, and a stronger support system throughout your journey.

What is Independent Surrogacy?

Independent (or private) surrogacy means you handle everything yourself. That includes finding intended parents, screening, legal contracts, medical scheduling, managing payments, and figuring out insurance—without the help of an agency.

Why First-Time Surrogates Shouldn't Go It Alone

If this is your first surrogacy journey, having an experienced team behind you really matters. Without that guidance, even small mistakes can affect your legal protection, your health coverage, or your overall experience.

An agency makes sure your contract is fair and enforceable, your payments are secure, and you're matched with intended parents who are fully ready—emotionally, financially, and legally. We also walk you through insurance, help with scheduling appointments, and stay by your side from start to finish.

Surrogacy is a beautiful and meaningful experience—but it comes with a lot of moving parts. You shouldn’t have to manage it all alone.

Should Experienced Surrogates Consider Independent Surrogacy?

Even for women who’ve done this before, independent surrogacy can get complicated quickly. Just because your first journey went smoothly doesn’t mean the next one will. Laws change. Insurance policies change. Every pregnancy is different.

Many experienced surrogates come back to us for their second or third journey—not because they had a bad experience going independent, but because they realize how much easier it is when someone else is handling the behind-the-scenes details.

Even if you already know the intended parents, having an agency involved protects both sides and keeps everything organized and professional—especially if something unexpected comes up.

Why Most Surrogates Choose to Work With an Agency

Surrogacy is rewarding, but it’s also complex. Legal agreements, insurance plans, medical scheduling, escrow payments—these are serious responsibilities, and they add up fast.

When you work with GSHC, we take care of those things so you can focus on having a healthy pregnancy and a positive experience. We’ll guide you through every step, match you with qualified intended parents, and make sure you're supported emotionally, medically, legally, and financially.

Many surrogates who’ve tried independent journeys come back to agency support—not because they had regrets, but because they realize how much more peace of mind it brings.

When Is Independent Surrogacy an Option?

In some rare cases, independent surrogacy might make sense—especially for experienced surrogates working again with intended parents they already know and trust. If you have a good legal team, understand how to manage escrow and insurance, and feel confident handling all the logistics, it’s possible.

But even then, things can change. New laws, medical complications, insurance delays—without an agency behind you, those problems are yours to solve alone.

That’s why, whether it’s your first journey or your third, most surrogates still choose the structure, protection, and partnership an agency offers. At GSHC, we’re here to make sure you’re supported every step of the way.

Want to talk it through or explore what your journey could look like with us? We’d love to connect.

Start Your Surrogacy Journey Today!

📩 Contact us now to learn more about becoming a surrogate mother and making a life-changing difference for intended parents!
📞 Call: 310-953-0137
📍 Apply to Become a Surrogate: Start Your Application Here

Follow Us for Surrogacy Insights & Updates!

📲 Stay connected and learn more about surrogacy through our social channels:

Ready to become a surrogate?

Apply Now