Choosing a surrogacy agency is one of the most important decisions in your surrogacy journey. The right agency ensures legal protection, financial security, and full support, while the wrong one can lead to stress, delays, and even financial loss.

When evaluating a surrogacy agency, consider the following key aspects:

1. Why Experience Matters When Choosing a Surrogacy Agency

Surrogacy isn’t a simple checklist. It involves real-life challenges—medical appointments, legal contracts, emotions, unexpected outcomes like failed transfers, and everything in between. An experienced agency knows how to guide you through all of it, with steady hands and clear answers.

At GSHC, we’ve supported hundreds of surrogate mothers over the years. We’ve seen the highs and lows of this process and learned how to navigate each situation with care and professionalism. That includes working closely with trusted fertility clinics, attorneys, and escrow providers to make sure your journey is smooth, your payments are handled properly, and your legal rights are never left to chance.

Before you commit to an agency, take the time to ask questions. Don’t just go with the first one you hear about. Compare. Learn about how they handle medical issues, communication, and finances. Most importantly, choose a team that makes you feel respected and safe—because that’s what you deserve.

2. Compensation & Financial Security: What Every Surrogate Should Know

When you’re looking into surrogacy agencies, it’s completely normal to compare compensation packages. After all, this is a major commitment, and you deserve to be fairly and thoughtfully compensated. But while a higher number might catch your eye, it’s just as important to look at who’s standing behind that offer. An experienced, reliable agency that truly supports you will make a much bigger difference in the long run.

At GSHC Surrogacy, we offer one of the most competitive and clearly structured compensation packages in the industry. Our payments cover your base compensation, monthly allowances, medical expenses, and a range of additional benefits—all laid out from the start so you’re never left guessing.

What a Good Agency Should Always Provide:

Secure payments through a licensed escrow provider, so you know your compensation is safe and will arrive on time
A clear breakdown of how and when you’ll be paid, including everything from your base pay to reimbursements and bonuses
Reliable, on-schedule payments that follow your contract—no surprises, no delays

If you’re comparing agencies, don’t be afraid to ask detailed questions. You’re not just choosing a number—you’re choosing people who will walk this journey with you. Look for a team that offers both fair compensation and strong, dependable support. That’s the combination that truly makes a difference.

3. A Bigger, Stronger Team for Better Support

When you’re choosing a surrogacy agency, it’s not just about the name or the website—it’s about the people behind it. A good agency will have a strong, experienced team that makes sure you never feel alone in this process. From case management to finances to emotional support, you should feel confident that someone always has your back.

You deserve a team that’s organized, responsive, and genuinely cares. Here’s what that should look like:

(a) A Case Manager Who Knows You Personally

You should have one main person—your case manager—who stays by your side throughout the journey. They’ll walk you through medical appointments, legal steps, embryo transfer preparation, and anything else that comes up. Their job is to keep things on track and make sure you feel supported the entire way.

(b) Clear and Secure Financial Support

Your compensation should be handled professionally and on time, without you ever having to chase it down. A good agency will have someone who manages your escrow account, tracks payments, and makes sure everything is paid out clearly and as agreed—no surprises, no stress.

(c) A Team You Can Reach

Life happens. People go on vacation, get sick, or have emergencies. That’s why a great agency makes sure more than one person knows your case. You should never feel like you're left waiting for answers. A strong team will always have someone available to help when you need it.

(d) People Who’ve Been There

One of the most comforting parts of working with an agency like GSHC is knowing that many of our team members have been surrogates themselves or worked closely with intended parents. They know exactly what this journey feels like—the highs, the challenges, and the deeply rewarding moments. That kind of understanding is something you can’t fake, and it makes a big difference in how you’re cared for.

4. Understanding Agency Culture & Values: Finding the Right Fit

Choosing a surrogacy agency isn’t just about the logistics or how much you’ll be paid. It’s about partnering with a team that respects you, listens to you, and stands for the right things. The agency you choose should feel like a steady, supportive presence—not just a service provider.

Here are a few things that truly set a trustworthy agency apart:

(a) Fair and Balanced Support

A good agency doesn’t take sides. They treat both surrogates and intended parents with equal respect, creating a space where everyone feels heard, protected, and valued.

You should never feel like just a “means to an end”
Your needs, preferences, and comfort should always matter

(b) Ethics Before Profits

The best agencies are driven by people—not money. They don’t push you into making decisions or offer inflated promises just to sign you on.

Compensation should be fair, clearly explained, and never used as bait
You should never feel rushed, pressured, or misled

(c) Honest and Open Communication

You deserve to understand every part of the process—medical, legal, emotional, and financial. A good agency walks you through each step without skipping the hard stuff.

No fine print or surprises
Full transparency, from start to finish

(d) Support That’s Actually Centered Around You

Surrogacy is a big journey, and it comes with real physical and emotional demands. You need a team that sees and supports you—not just the outcome.

Legal protections and medical guidance you can trust
Someone to talk to when you have questions, concerns, or just need to vent

(e) Real Community, Not Just Check-ins

You’re not doing this alone. The right agency will connect you with other surrogates who’ve walked this path and understand what you’re going through.

Peer support groups or surrogate communities
Real conversations, not just routine checklists

(f) A Team That Listens—and Adjusts When Needed

No two surrogacy journeys are the same. Life happens, feelings change, and sometimes plans need to shift. A strong agency will work with you, not against you.

Flexible, compassionate support that meets you where you are
Guidance that’s tailored to your real-life circumstances

5. Key Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Surrogacy Agency

Selecting the right surrogacy agency is crucial for a smooth, well-supported, and legally protected journey. Asking the right questions helps you assess the agency’s experience, reliability, and commitment to both surrogates and intended parents.

General Experience

How many years has your agency been in operation?
How many surrogacy cases have you successfully handled?
What makes your agency different from others in the surrogacy industry?
Do you have experience working with surrogates in my state, and are you familiar with local surrogacy laws?

Intended Parents & Matching Process

Where are the intended parents from? Are they from the U.S. or international locations?
What fertility clinics and surrogacy attorneys does your agency partner with?
How long does the matching process typically take?
How many intended parents are currently on your waiting list?

Agency Team & Support

How many people are on your team, and what are their roles?
Will I have a dedicated case manager?
What kind of support do you provide during the pregnancy?
Do you offer mental health support for surrogates?

Surrogacy Compensation & Financial Security

What is the base compensation for surrogates?
Are there additional benefits or allowances (e.g., maternity clothing, travel expenses, lost wages, childcare, etc.)?
How and when will I receive my payments?
Is my compensation held in a secure escrow account?
What happens if the pregnancy does not progress as planned?
Are there any out-of-pocket expenses I need to be aware of?

Start Your Surrogacy Journey Today!

📩 Contact us now to learn more about becoming a surrogate mother and making a life-changing difference for intended parents!
📞 Call: 310-953-0137
📍 Apply to Become a Surrogate: Start Your Application Here

Follow Us for Surrogacy Insights & Updates!

📲 Stay connected and learn more about surrogacy through our social channels: